Why Quad9 Is Right to Leave France

On November 24, Quad9 stops serving users in France. A Paris court ordered the Swiss non-profit to block a list of pirate sports streaming domains, with a daily fine until it did, and Quad9 decided to leave the country instead. I think they made the right call. Orders like this one leave French users less safe, and they don’t stop any piracy.

What the Court Ordered

beIN Sports asked the Paris Judicial Court to make Quad9 block domains carrying pirated tennis streams, a list that grew to 58 names. beIN wanted €10,000 a day for each domain still reachable through Quad9, or €580,000 a day. On October 21 the court set the penalty at €1,000 a day. An appeal is pending.

€1,000 a day sounds survivable. The trouble is the queue behind it: Quad9 says about 20 more cases are pending in France, covering hundreds of names, and its earlier fight with Sony in Germany cost six figures. It’s a free service run by a foundation, and in Quad9’s words, “the opposition has more lawyers than we have money and time.”

Two Ways to Comply

Quad9 laid out its options in the announcement. Neither works.

Option What it means
Add the names to the global blocklist A French court decides what users in every other country can resolve
Block them only for users in France Quad9 has to work out where each user is. In Germany a plaintiff got around exactly this kind of geoblocking with a VPN, and Quad9 was fined for contempt

The second option has a deeper problem. Quad9 has no sign-up and no accounts, and it keeps no database tying users to countries. To block by country it would have to start tracking where its users are, and privacy is a big part of why people chose it in the first place.

What 9.9.9.9 Is For

Quad9’s main service already blocks domains. It refuses to resolve hosts on a threat list built from intelligence supplied by more than a dozen security companies, so a phishing link or a malware callback goes nowhere. Here’s a domain that’s on the list:

$ dig @9.9.9.9 isitblocked.org A
;; ->>HEADER<<- opcode: QUERY, status: NXDOMAIN, id: 42633
;; flags: qr rd ad; QUERY: 1, ANSWER: 0, AUTHORITY: 0, ADDITIONAL: 1
; EDE: 17 (Filtered)

$ dig @9.9.9.10 isitblocked.org A +short
74.208.236.124

The filtered resolver answers NXDOMAIN and tags the answer with extended DNS error 17, “Filtered”. The unfiltered service at 9.9.9.10 resolves the same name. Users pick the one they want.

So the machinery the court wants already exists. The question is who gets to put names on the list. Today it’s security researchers flagging threats to the people using the service. A court order adds anyone with the budget to sue, and as Quad9 wrote, “Once the tools of censorship are built, they are rarely used sparingly or justly.”

Who Actually Loses

The streams stay up. Blocking at a resolver doesn’t take anything offline, and anyone who wants the stream can switch resolvers in under a minute.

The people who lose are Quad9’s French users, and Cloudflare points out that they include government bodies, schools, hospitals, and utilities. Quad9 can’t warn them, because it doesn’t know who they are. Anyone who misses the news finds out on the 24th when names stop resolving. Some devices, like cameras and thermostats with 9.9.9.9 built in, may be hard or impossible to fix at all.

Where They Go Next

Losing the malware filtering is the obvious cost. The bigger one is losing a resolver they had good reason to trust.

Every DNS lookup tells the resolver what you’re about to visit. Quad9’s privacy policy says it doesn’t collect or record user IP addresses, and it doesn’t share, sell, or rent anything that could identify a user. It applies the strictest of the Swiss, EU, and US definitions of personal data to every user, wherever they are, and it publishes a transparency report.

Now its French users have to pick something else. Quad9’s own notice says there are thousands of other open resolvers, with “lower trust, safety, and reliability.” The one a busy office lands on might log every lookup and sell what it learns, or it might just go down more often. Most of the people switching on short notice won’t have time to read anyone’s privacy policy, and each time a resolver like Quad9 leaves, there are fewer good ones to choose from.

If You’re in France

Look for Quad9 before the 24th. Its addresses are 9.9.9.9 and 149.112.112.*, IPv6 2620:fe::*, and the encrypted endpoints are under quad9.net. On a Linux box:

grep -rnE '9\.9\.9\.|149\.112\.112\.|2620:fe::|quad9\.net' \
    /etc/resolv.conf /etc/systemd/ /etc/NetworkManager/ \
    /etc/unbound/ /etc/dnsmasq* 2>/dev/null

Then check the places grep can’t reach: the router’s WAN DNS settings, the DHCP scopes that hand resolvers out to clients, and any appliance with its own DNS field.

This Keeps Happening

OpenDNS pulled out of France and Portugal in June 2024 over a Canal+ blocking order. In Belgium, DAZN has an order against Google, Cloudflare, and OpenDNS, with penalties of €100,000 a day on match days. Cloudflare says blocking has to start by early January, and all three have appealed. Each round, the resolvers that won’t rewrite answers leave, and the ones still serving are the ones that will.

It doesn’t have to go this way. In 2023 the Higher Regional Court in Dresden ruled for Quad9 against Sony. It found that a resolver plays no central role in publishing anything, and that a rightsholder has to go after the host first. That’s where the content lives, and taking it down there removes it for everyone, whichever resolver they use.